Imagine being told you cannot receive the aged care support you need, even when a qualified assessor sitting across from you knows the decision is wrong. Not because of your circumstances, not because of your medical needs, but because a computer has made the call and the person assessing you cannot change it.
For older Australians trying to remain independent in their own homes, that is an unacceptable way to determine something as important as their care.
Federal Member for Dawson, Andrew Willcox MP, has slammed the Albanese Labor government's aged care assessment system, calling for the restoration of human decision-making following damning findings from the Commonwealth Ombudsman.
“Older Australians deserve dignity, compassion and common sense when it comes to their care. They should never be reduced to a computer-generated score,” Mr Willcox said.
“Across Dawson, from Mackay to Townsville, the Burdekin and the Whitsundays, I hear the same message from older residents. They want to stay in their own homes, surrounded by their families and communities, for as long as possible.
“Whether that's a few hours of care each week, a rail beside the shower or a ramp at the front door, these are practical supports that can make an enormous difference to someone's independence and quality of life.”
Since November 2025, Labor's aged care assessment system has relied on a computer algorithm to determine support allocations and waiting priorities, without allowing qualified assessors to directly override its decisions.
Mr Willcox said the situation was reminiscent of the famous British comedy sketch in which a customer is repeatedly dismissed with the words “computer says no”.
“It was funny on television, but there's nothing funny about an older Australian being denied appropriate care because a computer's decision takes precedence over the judgement of a trained professional,” he said.
The independent Commonwealth Ombudsman has now delivered a damning assessment of Labor's aged care algorithm, finding the system “unreasonable” and warning that “a reasonable person would… lack confidence that the system is in fact fair and consistent”.
The Department of Health sought to have the Ombudsman reconsider his finding, but the Ombudsman refused.
The investigation also found that assessors were unable to override algorithm-generated decisions, even where those decisions were considered “clinically inappropriate”.
“Think about that. A qualified assessor in Dawson could sit with an elderly resident, understand their circumstances and recognise that the computer has made the wrong call, yet be powerless to correct it,” Mr Willcox said.
“That is bureaucracy overriding professional judgement, and it's older Australians who are left paying the price.”
Coalition senators joined with the crossbench to pass legislation restoring the ability of qualified assessors to override the algorithm, but the Albanese government has refused to bring the Bill forward for a vote in the House of Representatives.
Mr Willcox also criticised Labor's handling of the Ombudsman's findings, including its failure to provide the report to the Senate while pursuing an alternative escalation pathway.
“The Ombudsman has made it clear that human oversight needs to be restored, yet Labor continues to resist the very change that would give qualified assessors the authority to correct inappropriate decisions,” he said.
“Labor's aged care algorithm should be scrapped. At the very least, the government must support the Coalition's legislation and restore the right of qualified professionals to make decisions based on the individual sitting in front of them.
“The older Australians who built our communities, raised families and contributed throughout their working lives deserve far better than this.
“I will continue fighting alongside my Coalition colleagues until common sense and professional judgement are restored to aged care assessments.
“When it comes to the health, dignity and independence of our seniors, ‘computer says no’ should never be the final word.”
ENDS
Contact: Amanda Wright | Media & Communications Adviser
P | 07 4944 0662 M | 0455 456 705 E | Amanda.Wright@aph.gov.au

